Using the Psychology of Color to Boost Your WordPress Website Conversions

When it comes to website design, one of the more important decisions you’ll make involves choosing the right colors. It’s a choice that can make or break your project, especially when you consider all the moving parts that go into creating a successful WordPress site.

Nowadays, chances are good that if own a website, you own a business as well. And the most important thing for a business website is to have a good conversion rate. If your website isn’t converting, your company might as well hang up a “Closed for Business” banner.

That’s why it’s important your website’s color scheme is planned, intentional – and most importantly – optimized for conversion.

In this article, we’ll take a look at how colors influence our lives and how they can be used to improve how your potential customers or clients perceive your site and brand. 

Why is Color So Important?

Color plays an important role in our everyday lives. It connects to our feelings in a unique way, making it a powerful marketing tool to harness when making design decisions. Your color choices need to reflect the message you want to share about your upcoming event or product. Usually, color is the first thing that will draw the eye and visually guide your visitors, which is why it’s important that the colors in your design are purposeful and have meaning in their use.

According to a Kissmetric’s infographic, 85% of shoppers base their decision on color alone. And according to the same infographic, proper use of color leads to an 80% increase in brand recognition.

Various other studies and tests have proven that color can increase memory, engage and increase participation, as well as inform.

If you take a deeper look at the infographic mentioned above, you can see that Kissmetrics suggests which colors you should use depending on the nature of your business. It would be easy to assume then that if you are a clothing store you should settle on a pink color scheme. But the decision-making process is not clear-cut and definitive answers don’t exist. I realize that’s not very helpful. But let’s take a look at how color theory works to glean a bit more info about how to land on the right color for your next site.

Color Theory

Color theory is a topic so broad and diverse that numerous books have been written about it. So we’ll stick to the basics here. Essentially, color theory can be broken down into three major parts as it refers to web design:

  1. Contrast. In layman’s terms, contrast is the difference between two colors. Contrast serves two functions in web design: it establishes readability as well as draws the viewer’s attention towards a specific element on the page. Whenever you are in doubt, the best practice is to choose a very light color for the background and a very dark color for the text itself.
  2. Complementation. Complementary colors are found opposite each other on the color wheel. For example, red’s complementary color is green and blue’s complement is orange. When used correctly, these colors can accent each other and make a very effective color scheme.
  3. Vibrancy. This refers to the general mood particular color sets: the brighter, warmer colors (red, orange, yellow) tend to energize us while darker, cooler shades (green, blue, purple) tend to be more relaxing and tranquil.

Color Meanings and Culture

Colors have different meanings across different cultures. The way we perceive a certain color may not be the same as someone from Japan or the Middle East.  When planning a website, it’s important to understand who your target audience is and how that particular culture views color associations. Web Designer Depot has a great breakdown of colors and their meanings cross-culturally. I’ve summarized them here:

Red

  • In western cultures, such as North America and Europe, red is the color of passion and excitement. It symbolizes danger, love, excitement, and power but it can also carry a negative connotation when connected to the countries that used to belong to the Eastern communist block.
  • In Eastern and Asian cultures, red represents happiness, joy, and celebration; and as such it is often worn by brides on their wedding day because it is thought to bring good luck and happiness.
  • In the Middle East, red represents danger and caution. Some also consider it the color of evil.

Orange

  • The West sees orange as the color of harvest and autumn. Traditionally, in the United States orange signifies the fall season beginning in September through to Halloween and then Thanksgiving in late November.
  • Indian cultures consider orange a sacred color while in Japan, orange symbolizes courage and love.
  • Finally, the Middle East associates orange with mourning and loss.

Yellow

  • In Western cultures, yellow is associated with warmth, summer, and hospitality. Oddly enough, in Germany, yellow is associated with envy whereas most of the rest of the world associates this feeling with the color green.
  • In Eastern and Asian cultures, yellow is not only considered sacred but imperial as well. In India, it symbolizes commerce.
  • Contrary to that, in Latin America and Egypt, yellow is associated with death and mourning. The rest of the Middle Eastern cultures view yellow as the color of happiness and prosperity.

Blue

  • Many Western cultures use blue for bank logos because it represents trust and authority. It’s also associated with the birth of baby boys and considered to be calming, soothing, and peaceful. In a negative context, it represents sadness and depression.
  • In Eastern and Asian cultures, blue is associated  with immortality and strength. Contrary to the western world, blue is a feminine color in China.
  • In Latin America, blue is often associated with religion due to the high presence of the Catholic church.
  • The Middle East sees blue as safe and protecting as it is the color associated with Heaven, spirituality, and immortality.

Green

  • While Western cultures associate green predominantly as the color of the Irish and luck, green also refers to nature, the environment, the protection of environmental causes, and progress. In a negative context green symbolizes envy or jealousy.
  • In Eastern and Asian cultures, green is the color of nature, fertility, and youth. However, it’s also associated with infidelity and exorcism.
  • In Latin America green is the color of death.
  • For the majority of the Middle East green represents strength, fertility, luck, and wealth and is most commonly associated with Islam.

Purple

  • In Western cultures, as well as most Eastern and Asian cultures, purple is the color of royalty and is associated with wealth and fame.
  • On the other hand, Latin America and Thailand see purple as the color of  mourning and death.
  • The Middle East sees purple as symbolic for wealth.

Pink

  • In Western cultures, pink is the color of femininity and signifies the birth of a daughter. It also represents sweetness, childhood, or fun.
  • In Eastern and Asian cultures, pink is also considered feminine where it also signifies marriage. The exception is China which, as stated above, sees blue as the feminine color.
  • In Latin America, pink is often used as a color for buildings, while the Middle East doesn’t tie pink with anything in particular.

Brown

  • Western cultures associate brown with the earth but also health or even barrenness. Brown is stable, dependable, and wholesome.
  • In Eastern and Asian cultures brown is the color of mourning while in Latin America brown discourages sales and is generally considered disapproving.
  • Middle Eastern cultures associate brown with the earth and comfort.

Black

  • The Western world sees black as the color of finality, death, formality, and mourning, as well as the color of control and force.
  • In eastern and Asian cultures, black represents masculinity and is the color for boys in China. It also symbolizes wealth, health, and prosperity, while in Thailand and Tibet, black is most closely associated with evil.
  • Like in the East, Latin America associates this color with masculinity and mourning.
  • Interestingly enough, Middle East uses black to symbolize both rebirth and mourning.

White

  • In Western cultures, white is the color of purity and peace. It is the color associated with weddings, hospitals, and holiness.
  • However, in Italy and Eastern and Asian cultures, white is used for funerals and represents sterility, mourning, unhappiness, and misfortune.
  • In Latin America, white has many of the same associations as in North America and is connected to purity and peace.
  • Similarly to black, the Middle East associates both purity and mourning with white.

Color and the Conversion Funnel

A conversion funnel helps you visualize and understand the flow your potential customers go through after they land on your website and take the desired action. In its most basic form, the conversion funnel has four main elements: awareness, interest, desire, and conversion. Let’s break them down:

Awareness

Awareness is all about attracting potential customers or clients to your site. This is the part of the funnel where they get introduced to your brand. They get familiar with your business, your company culture, and your mission statement. This is where colors start to play a major role. By knowing who your target audience is and knowing the emotions you want to evoke, you can start planning your overall color scheme.

Interest

At this stage, you are working to pique the interest of your website visitors. You want to guide them to explore further and dive deeper into your website. Your energy should be focused on polishing headlines, images, banners, and writing a compelling copy.

Desire

Now that you have their interest, you have to make them really want your product. Your website’s imagery, great product options, videos, and testimonials should provide all the necessary information that they need in order to take action.

During the website planning stage, you should choose 3 colors that will represent your brand’s website. The general rule of thumb is typically to use neutral colors such as white or black for the background and use your main brand color to create a visually striking effect. Your primary brand color could be used for links, navigation menus and headlines. The third color should be an accent color from your brand palette that will serve one specific purpose. That brings us to the fourth stage of the conversion funnel.

Conversion

This is where the visitors take your desired action or in other words, convert. What that action is, depends entirely on you but the main goal is that they take action. This is where you need to draw their attention to that one single action. The best way to do that? Use the accent color from your color scheme. This is where you want a color that compliments your color scheme but is contrasting enough to draw the eye to your main call-to-action.

In other words, if your website uses mainly blue then it would make little to no sense to make your call-to-action button a darker shade of blue. Using a color like orange or a shade of yellow or red would be more beneficial.

Do, however, make sure your call-to-actions contrast with your brand colors enough to stand out, but not clash. You want it to draw people’s eye, pushing them toward conversion, not scare them off with an unappealing color scheme.

How to Color Optimize Your WordPress Website

Now that you know what colors mean and how the conversion funnel works, let’s discuss how to come up with a color scheme for your website that is optimized for conversion.

Planning your website color scheme is an integral part of your conversion strategy. Your personal color preference matters very little in this respect. Before you even embark on that stage, you should bear in mind what the primary goal of your website is and who your target audience is.

Based on your audience, your color scheme will be different if your target audience is female then that of someone whose target audience is teens and young adults.

While you may think that you can’t go wrong with pink if you are targeting women, you might be surprised to find out that roughly 35% of the women prefer blue as their favorite color, followed by green and purple.

Estēe Lauder makes a great use of blue on their website:

The Esteé Lauder website uses blue as a primary color
The Esteé Lauder website uses blue as a primary color

While Colour Pop targets the same female audience but with a purple color scheme:

Colour Pop is targeted to women and uses purple to zero in on its audience.
Colour Pop is targeted to women and uses purple to zero in on its audience.

To further complicate things, Jimmy Choo targets a female audience, too, but it  focuses its website colors on an elegant black and white scheme which is meant to provide a sense of luxury and sophistication.

The Jimmy Choo site definitely targets women but it uses black and white.
The Jimmy Choo site definitely targets women but it uses black and white.

Men, on the other hand, prefer blue, followed by green and black, while the younger population prefers blue, green and purple, with purple becoming increasingly popular with older age groups.

Dewalt does a great job with its black and yellow color scheme; black being a third favorite color for men and the color that signifies masculinity and force. Yellow provides an excellent contrast color in their call-to-action and tagline.

 

Dewalt targets men with a black and yellow color scheme.
Dewalt targets men with a black and yellow color scheme.

How to Determine the Best Color for Your Call-To-Action

Unfortunately, there is no clear-cut answer to this question. In terms of call-to-action buttons on the web, red, orange, and green are predominantly used. When you consider the fact that green usually signifies GO it’s no surprise that many have tried to translate that to the web. However, a number of studies have shown that green is not the optimal choice for a CTA.

A study by HubSpot shows that their red button outperformed the green one with a 21% increase n conversion rate.

Similarly, a study by Dmix shows a dramatic increase in conversions when a red button replaced the green one, improving conversions by 34%.

Amazon, on the other hand, shows that orange can be used effectively as a call-to-action color. If you look at their website, you’ll notice their most important call-to-actions are orange, which is an excellent choice for a company that wants to come off as approachable as possible.

10 Best WordPress Plugins to Increase Your CRO

Because you shouldn’t have to go this whole color optimization thing alone, we’ve put together a handy list of plugins you can use to ensure your color choices are actually working for you.

  • OptinMonster

    Screenshot-OptinMonster

    OptinMonster is a lead capture pop-up that offers plenty of features. With OptinMonster, you can create stunning lead capture forms using their drag and drop builder and you can customize every aspect of it. Though the plugin offers a nice collection of themes as a starting point, you can design your own in a matter of minutes. Its main strength lies in exit-intent technology which recognizes when the visitor is about to leave your website and displays a pop-up form at that precise moment. Another benefit of OptinMonster is that you have the ability to test different opt-ins and see which ones convert the best.

    OptinMonster is a premium plugin and pricing starts at $9 per month for one site (or $49 if you choose a yearly plan), with the most expensive plan being $29 per month for use on an unlimited number of sites (or $199 if you opt to pay yearly).

    Interested in OptinMonster?

  • OptimizePress

    Screenshot-OptimizePress

    OptimizePress is an excellent low-cost option for those of you who want to dive into creating custom landing pages. With OptimizePress, you can create sales pages, landing pages, custom membership sites and more. Their editor is easy to use and you can view all the changes as you make them which means you don’t need to refresh you page or preview to see what the design will look like. They offer a nice selection of pre-designed themes to get you started, as well as over 40 custom elements that add different functionalities to your website.

    OptimizePress offers three different pricing packages: the Core package at $97 for use on 3 sites, the Publisher Package at $197 for use on 10 sites, and the Pro Package at $297 for use on 30 sites.

    Interested in OptimizePress?

  • ExtraWatch

    Screenshot-Extra-Watch

    ExtraWatch is a helpful plugin which lets you form great CRO insights and test ideas by showing you visitor click maps of your WordPress pages and posts. With this plugin, you can optimize your landing pages by viewing heat maps, track clicks, view the performance of your buttons, and see which elements of your website are the most popular. It offers a different insight into your visitor’s real-time behavior and is available in a free and premium plan.

    Their premium plan costs a one time payment of $19.

    Interested in ExtraWatch?

  • Q2W3 Fixed Widget

    Screenshot-Q2W3-Fixed-Widget

    Q2W3 Fixed Widget is a plugin that gives you the option to mark any widget as  “fixed” widget to your sidebar. That means that no matter how far down the user scrolls, the widget will always remain visible which can dramatically increase the conversion rate on your most important call-to-action.

    This plugin is free.

    Interested in Q2W3 Fixed Widget?

  • Gravity Forms

    Screenshot-Gravity-Forms

    If you are working with forms and want to make sure they convert, then Gravity Forms should be your first stop. They are highly customizable and allow you to quickly and easily integrate with a variety of third-party services such as PayPal, MailChimp, FreshBooks and many others.

    Gravity Forms is a premium plugin available for $39.

    Interested in Gravity Forms?

  • Welcome Gate

    Screenshot-Welcome-Gate

    Recently, many popular bloggers integrated welcome gates on their websites. In case you are wondering what a welcome gate is, it’s a full-screen overlay that is placed on your homepage when a visitor lands on your website. Welcome Gate offers the user two choices: they can either sign up for your offer or they can skip that and continue straight to your site. This plugin’s author claims that using a welcome gate is 10 times more effective than using a pop-up.

    This plugin is free for a limited time.

    Interested in Welcome Gate?

  • Title Experiments Free

    Screenshot-Title-Experiments-Free

    A great headline can make all the difference between your post getting read or skipped over in favor of another post with a catchier title. Title Experiments Free lets you configure different headlines for your posts and see which ones convert better. Each headline you create is displayed randomly and the plugin ensures each unique visitor sees a different title. A returning visitor, however, will always see the same title they originally saw.

    Title Experiments Free is free. A premium version of the plugin with more advanced features is available as well for $29.99/year.

    Interested in Title Experiments Free?

  • Total Feedback

    Screenshot-Total-Feedback

    One of the best ways to understand your site’s performance is by gathering feedback from real users. Total Feedback allows you to create unlimited polls that appear in a small unobtrusive popup. The poll collects feedback from your visitors so you can eliminate guesswork and know exactly what to do to improve your site.

    Total Feedback offers three pricing tiers: Personal at $29.99 for use on a single site, Network at $69.99 for 5 sites, and Web shop at $149.99 for use on unlimited sites.

    Interested in Total Feedback?

  • A/B Theme Testing

    Screenshot-AB-Theme-Testing

    Our very own A/B Theme Testing plugin allows you to compare two themes and find out which one works best. You can choose to compare different versions of one theme or several completely different themes and it integrates with Google Analytics. There is no limit to the number of themes you want to test. Thanks to this plugin, you can eliminate the guesswork and improve your conversion rates without getting your hands dirty with code.

    A/B Theme Testing costs $19 per month on its own or $49 per month as a part of a WPMU DEV membership.

    Interested in A/B Theme Testing?

  • AB Press Optimizer

    Screenshot-AB-Press-Optimizer

    Thanks to AB Press Optimizer, you can create and test dozens of different versions of your images, buttons, content blocks, forms, and headlines. You can track the status of your experiments in real time as customers are visiting your site. The plugin is flexible enough to let you test any element on your theme, page, post, or custom post type.

    AB Press Optimizer is available as a free plugin with limited feature set. The premium version of the plugin with advanced features costs $49 for a personal license on one site, $99 for a business license on 3 sites, and $199 for an agency license on unlimited sites.

    Interested in AB Press Optimizer?

 

Wrapping Up

We’ve covered a lot today. The main takeaway about color optimization you should know is that there is no clear-cut answer here. Each website is unique and as such, each website will have a unique conversion rate optimization process.

As a starting point, however, you can narrow the potential colors of your call to action buttons to a few options that are in line with your theme or present a significant contrast. Avoid choosing colors that might have a negative connotation to your target audience. And don’t forget to test, test, and test some more and pick the winning color based on those results.

Bear in mind that color itself isn’t the magical solution. Your color choice is only one part of your marketing strategy, so be sure to complement it with stellar copy and a nice design. Otherwise,  your color choices won’t make much of a difference.

What are your favorite CRO techniques? Which color performs best for you? Let us know in the comments below.