Choosing a WordPress Management Dashboard: The Ultimate Guide

Management dashboards can help you manage all your sites in bulk to increase your efficiency and productivity, saving you oodles of time. But with so many options out there, which one should you choose?

Dashboards for WordPress sites list all of your sites, plugins and themes in one super convenient location. They also let you update everything in one or two clicks, whereas if you didn’t use a dashboard, you would have to visit each of your sites individually to make updates.

Seems simple enough until you realize each option out there has different features and settings. It can quickly get dizzying, so to alleviate some of that overwhelm, this post covers:

  • What you need to know about management dashboard for WordPress and how they differ from Multisite
  • The benefits and drawbacks
  • Criteria you should keep in mind to help you choose the best option for you
  • A review of the top six management dashboards currently available
  • A comparison of all of the reviewed dashboard managers

All of these details should help you make an informed decision so without further ado, let’s get to it.

Click here to go straight to my reviews of the top six management dashboards.

What is a WordPress Management Dashboard?

The main purpose of any management dashboard for WordPress is to provide a way for you to maintain all of your sites and the updates that become available for your plugins and themes in one place. This is done through a single page where you can connect all your sites and manage them in bulk.

The centralized location of the dashboard also lets you manage all of your sites without needing to log in to each and every time. It goes without saying that it helps boost your overall productivity and efficiency by giving you a quick way to manage your sites.

How is Multisite Different?

By now, you may be wondering “why is she describing the super admin dashboard of WordPress Multisite and calling it by a different name?” Actually, management dashboards are very different from Multisite.

While there are clear similarities, the biggest difference is that management dashboards let you manage all or your sites, whether they’re from the same or separate Multisite networks or single installs of WordPress. You can also link up sites from different servers to a management dashboard.

With Multisite, you can only manage sites within your network. Also, if you want to activate a plugin or theme on only a few of your subsites that aren’t network activated, you would need to go to each site separately and activate the plugin or theme, then go to the other sites and do the same.

With a management dashboard you can:

  • Manage plugin and theme updates in bulk: You’re able to deactivate and activate plugins and themes on multiple sites at once, all from the same page.
  • Access sites either externally or internally: You can manage your sites from a dashboard outside all your sites and from one that offers the management dashboard or as a plugin where you can link up all your sites to one WordPress installation.
  • Push WordPress updates to a select number or all sites: In addition to being able to toggle plugin and theme updates, you can also choose to update the WordPress installations for your sites.

There are also some other features that some management dashboards have that others don’t:

  • Deployment options: Install, delete, deactivate and activate plugins or themes across all your sites
  • Uptime monitoring: See and get notified if your site experiences any downtime
  • Backups: Backup some or all of your linked sites so you have a copy of them in case something goes wrong
  • User management: Bulk manage users for your sites including adding, editing and deleting users
  • SEO tracking or Google Analytics: See traffic and SEO statistics or get access to Google Analytics from the dashboard
  • Security: Malware scanning or other types of security scans
  • Content and comment management: Edit, delete, write or mark comments as spam for your sites in your dashboard as well as write and edit posts.

Some options do include other settings, but these are the most common features that you can usually find in different combinations for different management dashboards.

The Benefits

There are some key features which make management dashboards an excellent tool. Here are the main benefits in detail.

Centralized Interface: Being able to manage all your sites in one place, no matter where they’re hosted or what network they may be a part of is an excellent way to keep things simple and efficient. After all, it’s easier to go to only one place to handle changes rather than many separate ones.

Efficiency and Productivity: Since everything you need to manage is within your reach or well, click, you can manage your sites a lot faster and in less time.

Create Income for Your Business: If you’re a developer or theme designer. You could manage your clients’ sites easily and include maintenance as an additional service to your business to create recurring revenue without having to do so much extra work.

Minimize Amount of Plugins Needed: Since many dashboard managers have multiple features included that are duplicated in the plugins you already have installed, you could eliminate all those extra plugins. In turn, this would speed up your site for a better user experience and SERP ranking.

Lightweight: In the case of external management dashboards, they’re hosted away from your server, which means your site doesn’t have to compete with your dashboard for resources such as storage space, memory and bandwidth. It leaves a lot more wiggle room for your site to run smoothly.

The Drawbacks

Unfortunately, there are also a few reasons why using a management dashboard may not be all it’s cracked up to be. Here’s what you need to look out for in detail.

Potentially Less Secure: For external dashboards, you’re relying on the security of the company which provides the dashboard so if they’re not keeping their service secure, your sites are placed at risk as well. It’s especially riskier if you sign into your sites from the dashboard.

It’s also important to note that any external dashboard manager should not store your login credentials at any point. Doing so would pose a serious potential security risk.

On the flip side, most options have top-notch security. Still, it’s a good idea to keep this in mind when you’re considering your options.

Drain on Resources: For internal management dashboards, you’re solely responsible for allocating the resources it takes to run it. If the plugin is bloated, it could seriously weigh down your server which means your sites wouldn’t have enough breathing room to run properly and your visitors could quickly take notice.

Internal management dashboards also have the added expense of being self-hosted. If the plugin isn’t free or you need premium upgrades, it may prove to be more hassle than it’s worth.

Counter-Productivity: Some management dashboards are so robust, using them can be tricky and have a steep learning curve.  If it takes you forever to figure it out and become comfortable with using it, you end up being a lot less efficient and productive. It would negate the whole reason for having a management dashboard.

You also need to make sure you’re able to carry out the bulk actions you need to for your sites. If you aren’t able to manage your sites the way you want, then this also defeats the purpose of having this kind of service.

SITE MANAGEMENT

Manage multiple WordPress websites with The Hub

The Hub is your mission control for monitoring the vital stats of all your sites, including uptime, performance and security. Add as many sites as you want – including Multisite networks – and receive instant security alerts, run performance scans, and get notifications when any of your plugins or themes need to be updated.

TRY WPMU DEV FREE LEARN MORE

Criteria for Narrowing Down Your Choices

Ultimately, this is why it’s important to shop around and make sure you pick a management dashboard that fits your particular needs. Here are the main details you should consider when choosing a suitable option.

Cost: Time and Money

As previously mentioned, the management dashboard you choose needs to be easy for you to use. If it’s costing you time to learn the ins and outs of it, it costs you your productivity.

It also helps if you know that you can pass on the expense to your clients. If you can charge them a monthly maintenance fee, it’s easier to justify the added expense.

Even if you can’t directly pass on the cost of the dashboard, you can still determine if it’s saving you time and money by providing you the opportunity to be more efficient in streamlining your work and process.

Ease of Use

Management dashboards are like snowflakes since no two are alike. This means that you may find certain options are more intuitive for you to use than others.  This also means not one dashboard is right for every single person out there. You need to try them out and pick the one you think will be fastest for you to use.

Support

The quality of support you receive should also be an important factor, possibly moreso than for other products and services. Since the goal of using a management dashboard is to make your life easier, why should you accept customer service that makes your life more difficult?

You should also be able to make feature suggestions that are taken seriously so you can make even quicker work of otherwise teadious tasks.

Internal or External

The age-old question: Do you choose an internal or external management dashboard? It’s important to decide what’s most important to you in the feature set they each bring.

Internal dashboards offer an increased level of security since you’re in complete control and don’t need to log in and share your personal information with anyone. On the other hand, you’re completely responsible for your server, site and dashboard’s security.

If keeping a tight and secure ship isn’t your forte, it may be best to leave it up to someone else to manage it for you.

Establish Your Needs

Make sure you know what features you need and choose a dashboard that has them since there are solutions out there that have little features when compared to others. This is especially important when you need to do a task in bulk, only to find out that you can’t.

Some services also only have a certain number of bulk managing settings while making other bulk actions premium so watch out for that.

Many management dashboards also have other premium extensions for added capabilities. Check out what kind of extensions are available (if any) and make sure you have what you need, but also that you have room to grow.

Privacy

As previously mentioned, you need to make sure you have the level of privacy you want. If not being required to login externally is important to you, then consider an internal solution.

It’s not likely an issue for most sites, but sometimes it’s an essential requirement. If you’re managing client sites, be sure to go through their privacy and security needs beforehand to be sure you can offer them maintenance services through the proper management dashboard.

Your Personal Criteria

At the end of the day, it’s ultimately up to you to decide which features are most important for your sites. One size doesn’t fit all in this case so you need to go with the management dashboard that will fit your specific needs. Don’t just pick a dashboard service based on one factor such as popularity.

Don’t just pick a dashboard service based on one factor such as popularity. Fortunately, you can refer to this post for pointers to make an informed decision.

Reviewing the Top 6 Dashboard Managers


These are the top six management dashboards out there. The best features of each are detailed below along with their individual strong points and drawbacks.

Please note: These reviews are current based on the pricing options available at the time this was written.

Perfect Dashboard

Perfect Dashboard

The Perfect Dashboard site.

The Good

  • Backups are free
  • You can test updates to make sure your sites work as expected
  • There's a visual comparison of your site before and after the update
  • All tasks such as updates are shown on a list for ease and clarity
  • With one click you can perform many actions such as update, backup, testing and cache clearing
  • Sites with too many errors after updating can be rolled back to previous version
  • Stellar support

The Bad

  • Doesn't include everything under one roof such as uptime monitoring and analytics
  • Bulk deployment options such as installing and deleting plugins isn't available

Perfect Dashboard

  • Ease of Use:
  • Features:
  • Value for Money:
  • Efficiency:
  • Support:
  • Overall:

ManageWP’s Orion

ManageWP’s Orion

ManageWP's site.

The Good

  • Includes many features under one roof
  • You can execute code from the dashboard
  • You can manage content and comments
  • Security scanning and speed tests are available for free
  • Premium add-on is available for checking your site's SEO ranking

The Bad

  • Backups are only available for single installs
  • Doesn't include deployment options such as bulk installing and deleting plugins

ManageWP's Orion

  • Ease of Use:
  • Features:
  • Value for Money:
  • Efficiency:
  • Support:
  • Overall:

MainWP

MainWP

MainWPs site.

The Good

  • By far, has the most features
  • There are a ton of free and premium extensions for just about everything
  • Includes deployment options such as bulk installing and deleting plugins
  • You can manage users from your dashboard
  • Many unique extensions that other management dashboards don't include

The Bad

  • You can't add Multisite networks in your dashboard
  • You can't update plugins and themes individually
  • Can't be activated on a Multisite installation

MainWP

  • Ease of Use:
  • Features:
  • Value for Money:
  • Efficiency:
  • Support:
  • Overall:

MULTISITE

We are the Multisite Experts. Period.

We’ve been developing plugins for WordPress Multisite for the past 10 years. With WPMU DEV you get our most popular plugins like Domain Mapping, Snapshot, Pro Sites, Support System, User Switching and bucket loads of others tailored specifically for Multisite! Woop!

TRY OUR MULTISITE PLUGINS FREE LEARN MORE

InfiniteWP

InfiniteWP

InfiniteWP's site.

The Good

  • All available updates are easily seen on the main page
  • Bulk deployment options are included for free
  • See details about all your sites without navigating away from the page
  • Free basic backups included

The Bad

  • Most options are only available as a premium subscription
  • There aren't many free features available

InfiniteWP

  • Ease of Use:
  • Features:
  • Value for Money:
  • Efficiency:
  • Support:
  • Overall:

Jetpack Manage

Jetpack Manage

Jetpack Manage's site.

The Good

  • The dashboard is similar to WordPress.com for easier navigation
  • The interface is clean and simple
  • Uptime monitoring, deployment options and site statistics are available for free
  • Many free features included in the Jetpack plugin

The Bad

  • You need a WordPress.com account
  • It's not a lightweight option if you plan on using many or most of its modules

Jetpack Manage

  • Ease of Use:
  • Features:
  • Value for Money:
  • Efficiency:
  • Support:
  • Overall:

CMS Commander

CMS Commander

CMS Commander's site.

The Good

  • Interface looks almost exactly like the WordPress dashboard
  • Has free features that many options don't include for free
  • Many options for affiliate bloggers and marketing agencies
  • Free two-factor authentication login is available

The Bad

  • The main page has too much information condensed in one area
  • Most features require a premium subscription

CMS Commander

  • Ease of Use:
  • Features:
  • Value for Money:
  • Efficiency:
  • Support:
  • Overall:

Comparing the Top 6 Dashboard Managers

Now that we have taken a look at each management dashboard solution individually, here are the top options compared side-by-side in each category.

Ease of Use

Ease of Use

  • Perfect Dashboard:
  • ManageWP’s Orion:
  • MainWP:
  • InfiniteWP:
  • Jetpack Manage:
  • CMS Commander:

Features

Features

  • Perfect Dashboard:
  • ManageWP’s Orion:
  • MainWP:
  • InfiniteWP:
  • Jetpack Manage:
  • CMS Commander:

Value for Money

Value for Money

  • Perfect Dashboard:
  • ManageWP’s Orion:
  • MainWP:
  • InfiniteWP:
  • Jetpack Manage:
  • CMS Commander:

Efficiency

Efficiency

  • Perfect Dashboard:
  • ManageWP’s Orion:
  • MainWP:
  • InfiniteWP:
  • Jetpack Manage:
  • CMS Commander:

Support

Support

  • Perfect Dashboard:
  • ManageWP’s Orion:
  • MainWP:
  • InfiniteWP:
  • Jetpack Manage:
  • CMS Commander:

Overall

Ease of Use

  • Perfect Dashboard:
  • ManageWP’s Orion:
  • MainWP:
  • InfiniteWP:
  • Jetpack Manage:
  • CMS Commander:

And the Winner is…

Well, there can’t truly be a winner since no one management dashboard is going to be perfect for everyone, but there are some recommendations that can be made based on each option’s best features:

  • If you’re looking for an external management dashboard, take a closer look at Perfect Dashboard, ManageWP, Jetpack Manage and CMS Commander.
  • For internal, self-hosted options, check out MainWP and InfiniteWP.
  • You can get all the features you need for personal sites with Jetpack Manage, MainWP and CMS Commander. These options have the core free features needed to manage personal sites and blogs in case you aren’t wanting a premium subscription. They’re also quite user-friendly.
  • For developers and agencies, Perfect Dashboard, ManageWP and InfiniteWP are among your best options to consider first since they have features and pricing options suitable for larger scale needs.
  • CMS Commander is the best option for marketing agencies, and affiliate marketers and bloggers with its detailed SEO statistics and many monetization tools.

At the end of the day, you need to determine your own specific needs and pick a management dashboard based on your personal criteria but these are the top options to get you started in your decision-making process.

Jenni McKinnon
Do you use a management dashboard or are considering using one? What features are most important to you? Which option is your favorite? Share your experience in the comments below to add your take on the top management dashboards.