301 redirect goes to registration instead of subdomain

I have set up a go daddy account to do a 301 redirect for
sbhustlers.org to
https://hustlers.serve.community
instead it goes to:
http://serve.community/wp-signup.php?new=sbhustlers.org

Do you know why this is happening and what I can do to fix the routing to sbhustlers.org goes to hustlers.serve.community?