404 Page Returned instead of Protected Content Page.

Pretty much sums it up to be honest. If i set the stranger to show up, whenever i go to a page that should be protected, it instead returns a 404.

If i set it to none, then i get an infinite redirect loop.

Would love to get this resolved so I don't have to look elsewhere. I'm going to read through the instructions again before bed, but I'm quite certain I followed them correctly. But who knows....