A Page is showing up as Protected Content even when I am signed in as a Member

Hello,

This page

http://gator4047.hostgator.com/~alex/voodoo-the-f-101-story-video

Should be a page that is protected content to "Visitors" of my website, but should be visible to "Members." For some reason it is redirecting to the Protected Content Page even when I am signed in as a Member. I have looked and everything else works great. All of my settings are correct. Please help. I can't figure out this bug!

Thank you so much!

Alex