As I continue trying to solve my site issues, I unzipped Membership to compare those files with my installed Membership files.
The most obvious difference is that in the installed Membership files there is a folder called Addons that's chalk full of php files.
The second obvious difference was that the installed files includes a Fancybox folder and files under JS. Is this bad?
Mostly, the site is looking pretty good except I've lost my pictures once again.
Thanks for all you do,