All content on pages disappears when membership is enabled

I set up membership with two levels and a default level. Currently all the levels have everything set to be visible in their settings but the only thing that shows up for each page is the title and none of the content,

I've tried tweaking all the settings but the content still won't show up on any page as long as the plugin is enabled. I'm able to see the content on my admin account but not on any of the test accounts I made the different user levels.

The site can be seen here http://test-server.pixelslip.com/testsite