All Members Are Not Showing Up

On my Members page at https://dating.christiangays.com/members/ it shows "All Members 37", however below that it says "viewing 1 - 20 of 154 members".

Unfortunately if you do a search for a member that is not one of the 37, it comes up with no results.

I have done plugin conflict test, changed themes, reinstalled BuddyPress, etc. It remains the same, even when new members register. It is always 37.

Please see screenshot.

Support Access is granted.