Am I missing something here. Upon initial setup I chose to have any 'visitor' locked out by 'no access to contect' (I did not select 'Visitor' from the dropdown). I have only 2 members in the All Members list: myself which is labeled 'Super User' and a fake user I created which has a level i deemed 'Level 1'. I then, under Options, selected a 'Protected Content' page in the Protected Content page section.
So, when I log off to test the protection there is no way to log in user the Theme's login boxes with the fake user or myself as the Super User. I have to go back to the hosting site and start over accessing the WP site each time. Thanks.