Autoposting a post to a Facebook page error

I've been through the discussions a bit and can't seem to find an answer to my little twist on the autoposting issue.

I've installed and configured Ultimate Facebook successfully including granting extended permissions.

Everything else the plugin supports (things like comments) seems to be working fine.

I have a post scheduled to hit at 4am in the morning and I'd like it to autopost to my page as well. I'm an admin of that page and I'm logged into Facebook.

It hasn't worked yet and this morning there was the following error:

OAuthException: (#210) Subject must be a page.

Additionally in looking through the discussions I found that there should be more options for Facebook when I post - see the attached screenshot for what it looks like in my post editor. I've seen other screenshots with more options than mine.