Avatar Upload not working: Bad location?

When I, or my users attempt to upload an Avatar, the avatar cropping feature seems to work just fine. However, after hitting the UPLOAD button, the image location seems to be wrong OR it's not uploading correctly.

I have multisite, and Avatars for Multisite Network activated. Avatars BBpress is NOT activated.
I checked file permissions, and everything seems to be in order.
I'm on the most current version of the plugin.

I have uploaded an image of the "broken file" as well as the URL the image is supposed to be housed at.

I am behind a vpn and cannot share my site. Please let me know what other information you may need. Thanks!