Blog Templates Not Working as Expected

I have created multiple templates and can see them when I go to the sign up page on my site. I can choose the template and make the payment but once the site is created the settings for the chosen template aren't being applied.

It defaults back to the 17 template versus the one selected. I just created a test site... http://www.mycraftblog.com/poochiecraft/

Is this not configured correctly for my multiple theme choices?