BuddyPress add-on is deactivating on main site when going to a subsite

I'm having an issue with Membership 2 Pro and BuddyPress on my multisite. Whenever I activate the BuddyPress add-on, it doesn't stay.

I activate it on the main site and right after visiting another site, when I come back to the main site’s membership settings the add-on is not active anymore.

I tried deactivating all plugins and only keeping the 2017 theme active on the network, but the issue is still there.