Buddypress profile page being blocked by Membership

I have my wp-login.php page setup so after someone logs on it takes them to their profile page. That part works correctly, but for some reason no matter what permission levels I give in the "Access Levels" part of Membership, the page always comes up as "Protected Content".

This is where they are being sent and what is being redirected to the protected page:

http://www.mysite.com/members/username/

Strangely, if I were to go to these pages it is unprotected:

http://www.mysite.com/members/
http://www.mysite.com/members/username/settings/

I've tried allowing all of the buddypress rules in the access pages section, and I've messed around with adding custom urls with a wildcard after "members/" but haven't found anything that will work yet.

Can anybody give me a hand? It's driving me crazy.

Thanks