Rupok shared the buddypress-profile-shortcodes plugin with me (Thank you Rupok!) and I think that it could be perfect except that the only shortcodes they provide are "alphabetical".
I particularly love [webim_members_carousel type="alphabetical" count="12" title="Alphabetical Members" visible="6"] however I need shortcodes to distinguish gender and another for location.
Would you know what is involved in adding shortcodes of, for example, Men, Women, Location, etc to the plugin?
I have written to the developers but I don't think the plugin is supported anymore.