Business Blog Only Showing 1 Post

Hi, I'm trying to show blog posts as my home page (renamed home.php to home123.php)

For some reason, I can't get more than 1 post to show up on the main page. In settings, I have it set to show 20 posts.

I've checked the category (20+ posts in category)... I've done this before on other sites without a problem.

site: churchofchrist.biz

If anyone can help me out, I'd appreciate it