Can you use Directory and Members Directory together and would you actually want to?

I am working on a site that I want galleries, artists, and restaurants etc. to set up a profile on where they can also upload pictures. I want site visitors to be able to search these profiles like a directory. Which plugins do you recommend using. There seem to be pros and cons to both the Directory plugin and the Members Directory. At some point we want to be able to charge for creating a profile and being on the site which is a feature of Directory. Does it make sense to use both plugins and is that even possible?