Changes not shown to logged out users

I just pushed my staging site to production bu the chnages at first did not appear to display on the production site. But I then discovered that they do show IF I am logged in, but if I am logged out, it still shows the previous version.

Suspicious, I went ahead and looked at my staging site in incognito mode (logged out), and sure enough, the changes do not show there either.

So why are my changes not being displayed to logged out users?

The change you should see is the icons in the "All Paid plans Include" section near the bottom of the home page.

Screenshot 1 is what you SHOULD see.

Screenshot 2 is what you do see IF not logged in.

Please note this is the main site of a multisite network.