Chat timestamp is 5 hours behind

Hello friends. I have an issue with my Chat timestamps being 5 hours behind my actual time-zone time. I have my General WP settings to New York (example: 8:51 am.) My chat will show 3:51 on the time stamps.

Another thing that is odd, is last night it was working just fine until about 9:00 pm. Then is self switched to 5 hours early.

Any ideas?

Thank you!