Clean up Subscription Page

URL http://www.alumniclubny.com

Versions
WordPress 3.5.1
Membership 3.4.3.1
PHP Version 5.2.17
MySQL 5.5.30-log

I have already tried disabling all of my other plugins.

The default subscription page (where you cancel, upgrade, etc.) is very confusing. Is there a way to create a custom page like this? I just want it to say something like “Current Membership: Social Membership, Expiration: January 14th, 2014” and have buttons for cancelling, upgrading, etc. Here is what it currently looks like for this paid member.