Confused. Maybe I am just tired as it is late.

Confused. Maybe I am just tired as it is late.
In A+ I check Login required = yes and allow the social sites to display login. If I am logged in I dont have an issue seeing the appointment.

If I log out, I dont get the login controls.

If I have login required set to no, and I am logged out of WP it says "Protected Content"

What the heck?

I have membership installed too, but dont really have it setup. Help.