Contact Form hidden, even though it shouldn't be

I’m using shortcodes to protect certain content on public pages, but one type of content I’m not trying to protect are a few different contact forms generated by Contact Form 7. None of the pages(created before I installed memberships) are displaying the forms properly for unlogged users anymore, and I’ve triple checked that there aren’t any naming conflicts.

I’m glad to see that content is being restricted, but how do I fix this? Also, I’ve disabled membership and the problem still persists.