Copying a table from another website looks weird

Hello, I set up this page:

But the client said he did not like it and wants it to look exactly like their old site:

What he means is everything inside of the blueprint background he wants to look and be formatted in the same way on the new site, the page listed first. I tried copying and pasting the HTML but it looks very strange (see the section below the original design I did on that same page).

Why is the copying of the HTML table not working? Why does it look strangely formatted? Is there anything I can do to accomplish what he wants besides remaking the table and what not (we've gone over in scope already).