Creating Appointment Manually Shows Start Time at 12:00am

When I make an Appointment manually it let's me choose the date and time and save it but when I look at it again and the confirmation email goes out it shows a start time of 12:00am and the end time is fine. I can go in and edit the start time but that is an extra step.

I deactivated all plugins and set the theme to Twenty Twelve but it still sets it at 12am.

Here are screenshots to show you what's happening. Screenshots

This is the same site that is at it's just being moved over to WP Engine.

Any help would be appreciated since there will be manual appointments set on the backend.