Custom Post types disappear when plugin is active

I’m having a very hard time getting to the bottom of this. I’m testing the Protected Content and when I’m logged in as the admin the my custom post types are displayed on my front page but when I’m logged out the Query returns nothing. Why would this happen?

I set up the plugin’s membership as “Multiple Content Types.”

I have two types of memberships.

I have only one page of protected content and it’s not the front page.