Did Smush It Smush the Profile Avatars?

I’ve been running this multisite for over 3 years with the same template theme. We are using the admin’s profile avatar (126 x 126) on homepage. I’ve recently re-activated Smush It on network and now all of the profile images are displaying smushed with the width correct but height is only 62px. What can I do to fix this? There are 125 active sites and all that I checked are doing the same. You can see the problem here: https://demo.usingessentialoils.com