I set up a new domain (registered the domain with namecheap) and installed it on my reseller account with Site5 (evidently they don't answer the support chat anymore. 4 attempts of waiting for more than 40 minutes in the past three days). I installed Cloudflare via my cloudflare panel (I have a pro account).
Now, when I visit my site (www.internetmarketerexpo.com) it loads word press without any issue. When I visit https://www.internetmarketerexpo.com I receive an error that reads
If you are the owner of this website, please contact your hosting provider:
It is possible you have reached this page because:
If I attempt to log into the wordpress admin panel at http://www.internetmarketerexpo.com I am redirected to the https version and it gives me an apache bluegreen screen.
If I check the domain the SSL certificate seems to be installed correctly. The IP addresses inside of cloudflare seem to match the ones listed inside the cpanel server information.
At this point I'm just pretty much at a lost. Any ideas?