Easy Blogging: options not sticking

WHAT I WANT:
All non-admins should have Easy Blogging as their ONLY mode. I think I've got all settings calibrated appropriately but either A) I'm missing something or B) the plugin isn't behaving as it should.

WHAT I'M DOING:
I have my Easy Blogging settings set to:
1. Force Easy Blogging on all subscribers/contributors
2. Hide "exit easy mode"
Screenshot of my settings page: http://awesomescreenshot.com/03cqxjia9

WHAT I EXPECT:
1. Subscribers log in and see Easy Blogging mode
2. There is no way to exit the mode

WHAT I'M SEEING:
1. When I log in as a subscriber, I do NOT see Easy Blogging as a default (I see standard WP)
2. When I manually activate easy mode via that ugly button that needs to be fixed, I see "exit easy mode" as an option: http://awesomescreenshot.com/040qxjp80