eNewsletter Subscribe Page - Form stuck on "Saving..."

Got the plugin installed and all set up, created a subscribe page. When I use the form to subscribe, the form just sticks with the word "Saving..." above it.

If I log in to the backend of the site, it appears that my subscription was successful, but I never go to the subscribe page, and never get an email (I'm not worried about the email at this time, I know what I need to do to fix that).

I really want people to go to the subscribe page after they enter their information...any idea what would make it behave that way (getting stuck)?