Entire site now just shows "protected content"

I enabled the membership plugin for my site and the following things happened:
1. the entire nav changed
2. my entire site went to protected content only
3/ There was no way to "unprotect" the pages and make things public, and I wasn't ready to start doing the entire public/private content.
4. I disabled and deactivated the membership plugin--no avail
5. I deleted the plugin.
6. MY SITE IS STILL 100% PROTECTED!
How is this possible? What is going on? Please help.
Site is julieelainebrown.com