Exceptions Not Working Properly

For some reason, exceptions no longer seem to inherit properly on this site. Today was a holiday for my center and I marked it as such in the settings. However, it's not being "inherited" to all my providers. Two appointments were booked for today, despite the fact that it's marked as an Non working day for no specific provider.

This is a big issue. Do I now need to specifically mark non-working days for each, individual provider? That's king of a pain, and isn't how it used to work.