Expired members still have access

In Members list on the site, find the user 11test_user. When you click on "subscription details" link underneath username, it shows that user's expired (not having access). However, if you instead click on the icon on the far right it's showing that members are active. Transaction logs show over 400 successful payment transactions for this user up until 14th when the PayPal gateway was replaced with Authorize.net. The user is still having access to protected content. There are probably more members like this.