Facebook Plugin is getting shut down or is crapping out somehow

When I go to a content page (free 1 click membership required) and click the FB like button...

a like is registered and it goes to 1 and a post to FB box comes up perfectly. After a couple seconds the box goes away and the FB like that was registered goes back to 0 even when I didnt touch anything. THe like gets completely reverted. Then after it happens the 1st time, and you try to click like again it immediately registers and goes away.

Do you think it could have something to do with the theme?

Please advise.
With Thanks