Fatal Error with Plugin New Blog Templates

I am trying to duplicate the main site many times over on a wordpress multisite network. When using New Blog Templates, I set up a template from main site then tried duplication. I get the error in the screenshots. I have set Max Execution Time Up to as high as 5 min but I get same error. When Doing this I get the email saying the new blog was set up but when going to that domain I see this:
It Should look like this: http://onlinemerchantconnection.com/

The goal is to duplicate this site dozens of times and use domain mapping to place them on their own urls