FREE Trial Offers are not working

I have created a MONTHLY subscription membership with a 1 day free trial period. (Picture included).

No credit card information is collected because of the free trial period.

The free trial period has expired according to the MY ACCOUNT screen - and the only button available is a CHANGE button.

When I go to the CHANGE area - there is no RENEW button or PAY NOW button - only cancel. There is also NO INVOICE.

What am I doing wrong for free trials / collecting credit cards for payment upon the end of the free trial?