Fundraising plugin looks different and missing progress bar on new site

This is correct:
- Bottom Page: http://ussunnah.org
- Right Sidebar: http://ussunnah.org/dawah-center-1

This is not correct:
- Bottom Page: http://139.59.240.223/
- Right Sidebar: http://139.59.240.223/dawah-center-1

I checked all options I could find and custom css in the theme.. still not finding why the two look so different. I can give admin access to both sites if needed but this has to get fixed ASAP as we are currently doing an active fundraiser.