Headline missing

This is a weird one and I would love to know if anyone can see under the hood. Page 2 is a copy of page 1. Literally, I took the source code, from page 1, created a new page, and pasted it into page 2.

Page 1 (the original page) is missing it's headline!

Page 1: http://www.idomagic.com/birthdays2/
Page 2: http://www.idomagic.com/birthdays/

Do any of you smarter WP people see what may have happened to the code on Page 1 to make the headline disappear?