How Can I protect an Entire Category of Content?

I'm still not getting this to work correctly. I only have one Access Level of subscription and I went ahead on the Access Levels options and added to the Positive Rules a set from the Menu where I selected an entire category which is what I want to be displayed for users only.

Now most of the pages are restricted as you can see here on the main nav, the menu Members Only should be all restricted content but there are 3 pages that are not being restricted:

Members Only > Resources > Sabbatical Information
Members Only > Presentation Library > Conference Webinar Presentations
Members Only > Presentation Library > Reports

What I don't get is why every other page is restricted by these 3 pages.