I'm still not getting this to work correctly. I only have one Access Level of subscription and I went ahead on the Access Levels options and added to the Positive Rules a set from the Menu where I selected an entire category which is what I want to be displayed for users only.
Now most of the pages are restricted as you can see here http://abc.djstechnologies.com on the main nav, the menu Members Only should be all restricted content but there are 3 pages that are not being restricted:
Members Only > Resources > Sabbatical Information
Members Only > Presentation Library > Conference Webinar Presentations
Members Only > Presentation Library > Reports
What I don't get is why every other page is restricted by these 3 pages.