How do I Access the Templates when I create a Newsletter?

I've got eNewsletter 2.2 loaded on the site, but when I go to create a newsletter, the only template it allows me to use (actually the only one that shows up when I try and select a template) is the "iLetter" template. I've checked the install on the site, and all of the templates are are present in the plugin's templates folder.

Not sure what to do or what is wrong. Any ideas? I've already tried deleting the plugin and reloading it.