How do I get the dashboard to log in properly?

I added the dashboard plugin to website.okeefeonline.com.au and the intro page suggested I get a 'free api key' or to 'login'.

I selected login as I am already a gold member with an annual sub, and I type my details in and it says 'Welcome OKeefe Online' and my avatar says im a gold member. But on the right of it, it says 'you are currently a free member upgrade your membership' and majority of features will not work for me...

Any idea how to resolve this?