[Hustle] eNewsletter Intergration – Member gets unsubscribed immediately

I have a Hustle embed set up to collect submissions and add them up to an e-Newsletter group.

I have about 15 people that have submitted the form. They have all been added to the correct list, but it also shows them as unsubscribed. I haven’t even sent out an email yet.

I can’t see how they all have already unsubscribed. Upon submission, they get an unsubscribed status, immediately. Please advice.