I can't get the search working properly. I am trying

I can't get the search working properly. I am trying to just show a list of posts. However sometimes it shows the full post. i can't figure out why. Here are two examples:

https://www.russcatanach.com/?s=test (This works as expected)

https://www.russcatanach.com/?s=test (This shows a post, which I do not want.)

Both show up ok in Upfront editing.

-Russ