I can't seem to get the custom sidebars to work per item that I add based on user level

I have visitor and member levels on this site (this is a clone of this site: manhattanwomensclub.com because I just did a wordpress, theme and plugin update and I'm testing things. If you are logged in as a member and go to this page for example (a member page) http://creategreatthings.com/mwc-current/member-directory/ The sidebar contains items that I have set in the widget area to be VISITOR only like the "subscribe" and and "joining" info. In the admin widget area - they are set to Visitor level only.

Thanks for your help!