I don not get a Protected content message

For example, on this page http://tinnitussynergy.com/tpt-test-page-for-protected-content/, it should show protected content message, but:
- For members, it shows content w/o restriction.
-For non-members, it goes to the Registration page, where it says : "We have the following subscriptions available for our site. To join, simply click on the Sign Up button and then complete the registration details. ..."

For this page, http://tinnitussynergy.com/aa-accesible-to-all-page-that-will-proceed-the-protected-content/ , it is NOT protected and should not show a message.
- For members, it shows content w/o restriction.
- For non-members, it shows content w/o restriction.

This is much closer to correct than what I have been dealing with over the last few months with this plug-in, but it still doesn't seem as intended.
Am I missing something simple?

I have granted access, if needed.

Thank NAME, for their help.

Let NAME know exactly why they deserved these points.

Gift a custom amount of points.