I enabled the custom template add-on. So that made

I enabled the custom template add-on.
So that made the comments plus box show.
When I post a comment (tested with facebook and twitter) the comments do not show on the page.

I added in the hooks at the top of the comments.php file after they would not show.
That did not help.

Link to an example page live: http://nbbymca.org/dallas-brass-to-perform-at-y/