I have 3 access levels: 1) Visitor 2) Free 3) Paid I have 2

I have 3 access levels:
1) Visitor
2) Free
3) Paid

I have 2 subscription options:
1) Free Member
2) Paid Member

I go to my website and register and sign up under the "Free Member" subscription.

I go to the subscriptions page and it says "Upgrade from Free Member" and presents me with the option to "Move to: Paid Member" but there is no button to pay and upgrade