I have the free version of custom sidebars installed

I have the free version of custom sidebars installed on https://preachnet.com

The problem is that not matter what sidebar I select on each page, the same sidebar keeps showing, and that is a custom sidebar I just made called Blog Sidebar.

Also, I have another sidebar set to show on the post types relate to BB Press, but the same thing happens on all those page - the "Blog" custom sidebar keeps showing.

Any ideas?