I installed the Avatars plugin and updated my theme

I installed the Avatars plugin and updated my theme to display the Author Box. However, no Avatar appears on the page.

I can upload the image and crop it. When I do this it says "Avatar updated." but nothing appears in the User settings or on the live site.

Here is a blog post where the Author Box is showing:
http://globallawfirms.org/blog/un-scientists-find-global-warming-faster-expected/

Thoughts?