Infinite showing up as 1 day in Free Membership

I'm using the membership plugin and I am having a problem with infinite memberships expiring.

http://screencast.com/t/pTVyF3HM1v6

As you can see in the above link, the free members are set to expire 1 day later.

However, as you can see here.. I have it set to infinite. What am I doing wrong?

http://screencast.com/t/0xNlK7MQgk

- Tony