Login and Logout Redirect URL not working

When a user logs in I want them to be directed to a specific page (the homepage) which I've tried setting as an absolute url and also a relative url in Listings > Settings > Redirect URL (sign in).

I've also set the Redirect URL (logout) to the homepage too.

However neither of these seem to work. When I log in it takes me to a 'Signup Complete page', and when I log out it takes me to the /wp-login.php?loggedout=true page.

Am I missing something? :slight_frown: